Blog/Commentary· 11 min read

Does AI Search Cite Brand Websites? We Measured 3,814 Citations in Beauty.

Yong Suk Choi, Chief Business Officer, BAZZAAL

By

Yong Suk Choi

Cover image - Does AI Search Cite Brand Websites? We Measured 3,814 Citations in Beauty.

Rarely. In a 2026 sample of 3,814 AI search citations in beauty, brand-owned websites made up 2.4%, and the rest came from creator videos, retailers, review threads and editorial sites. Many Korean agencies are selling the same AI search checklist: add schema, publish an llms.txt, rewrite your product pages as text. We spent a week reading the research behind those recommendations and testing real K-beauty storefronts ourselves. Much of the checklist has little evidence behind it, and controlled tests found limited benefits.

What we found: tracking only ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity misses part of the market. Every AI crawler user agent we tested could fetch our pages in full, so access was not the problem. Controlled studies found little benefit from the tactics being sold. And in beauty, AI engines mostly cite pages that brands don't own.

Which AI engines actually matter in 2026?

ChatGPT and Gemini lead, but Meta AI belongs on the list too. Pew Research surveyed 5,119 US adults in February 2026, and Meta AI reached about as many of them as Grok and Claude combined.

Bar chart of US adult usage by AI chatbot: ChatGPT 44 percent, Gemini 24, Copilot 17, Meta AI 14, Grok 8, Claude 6, Character.ai 3

Meta AI runs on Llama, an open-weight model, and reaches about as many US adults as Grok and Claude put together.

The companies behind open-weight models are also building their own web search. Mistral documents two crawlers, one for live answers and one for its own search index. Meta's crawler documentation now lists Meta-WebIndexer, described as crawling the web to cite and link content in Meta AI's responses. Alibaba runs TongyiBot for Qwen. Anthropic added Claude-SearchBot. OpenAI added a bot that validates ad landing pages.

We tested access by fetching our own homepage with each operator's documented crawler user agent.

Table showing six AI crawlers fetching bazzaal.com, all returning HTTP 200 with 2,357 words of body text

We got the same result on a case study page. Our robots.txt is a single Allow rule, and we changed nothing for this test.

One caveat. A company running its own copy of Llama, Qwen or DeepSeek gets a model that cannot see the web on its own. The search service plugged into it, usually Brave, Exa, Tavily, Serper or Bing, decides what it can cite, so there is no way to optimize for Llama itself. Brave is the hard case: its own documentation says its crawler deliberately does not advertise a distinct user agent, so you cannot confirm from your server logs whether you are in that index.

Do AI engines cite the same sources?

No. The engines cite very different sources, so getting chosen by one says little about the others.

Chart of citation overlap between AI engine pairs, Jaccard 0.119 to 0.237, with only 3.8 percent of sources agreed on by all four engines

Writesonic ran 161,286 prompts across four engines. The comparison uses the 70,879 prompts where all four engines returned citations.

The closest pair, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, shares less than a quarter of its cited domains. ChatGPT and Gemini share 12%. About three quarters of the cited domains appear on only one engine. Only 3.8% of sources were cited by all four. A single blended AI visibility score hides those differences, and a win on one engine may not carry over to another.

Does llms.txt work? Does schema improve AI citations?

Not in the evidence we found. Neither llms.txt nor FAQ schema has been shown to increase AI citations, and we were about to implement some of it ourselves.

The original GEO paper is often misquoted. Aggarwal and co-authors (KDD 2024) reported up to a 40% improvement, a number that now shows up in Korean agency pitches. That 40% is not traffic. It measures how visibility shifted among sources that were already in the top five results. In the same paper, keyword stuffing lowered the metric from 19.3 to 17.7, and an authoritative tone showed no significant improvement. The widely quoted 115% applied to the site ranked fifth in traditional search results. For the site sitting first, the same table shows a 30.3% decline.

Controlled tests mostly failed to reproduce the gains. C-SEO Bench (NeurIPS 2025) tested the published methods and found statistically significant effects in only 3 of 54 cases, and none on question-answering tasks. Several methods significantly reduced rankings. The authors conclude that these tactics compete for a fixed amount of visibility and work alongside traditional SEO, not instead of it.

Optimizing the body copy alone made things worse. SAGEO Arena (KDD 2026) built a corpus of 2,700 queries over 171,003 documents and measured each stage separately. Rewriting body text alone made documents 9% less likely to be retrieved, on average. Adding structure raised the retrieval hit rate by 22%, but those gains did not turn into more citations once the system ranked the results.

Almost nobody reads llms.txt. Google's own guidance on generative AI features says, in a mythbusting section, that machine-readable files like llms.txt are not needed and that Google Search does not use them. Ahrefs then checked 137,210 domains: of the 28% that publish an llms.txt, 97% received zero requests for it in May 2026. Of the requests that did arrive, 96% were bots and 77% of those bots were not AI tools. We deleted the llms.txt we had already written.

FAQ rich results are gone. Google deprecated them on May 8, 2026 and removed the documentation on June 15, 2026. Bing has said clear headings, tables and FAQ sections help it cite pages accurately, but that refers to question-and-answer text readers can see on the page, not FAQ markup.

Are Korean product pages unreadable to AI crawlers?

Partly. AI crawlers can read the HTML of Korean product pages, but they miss claims and usage instructions that sit inside images. A Korean industry study published by Openads crawled 370 Korean direct-to-consumer sites and reported that 65.5% had no sentence answering any of 50 common customer questions, with beauty the worst category at 86.2%. We did not verify Openads' findings ourselves.

We checked the US side ourselves. We pulled three product pages each from five K-beauty US storefronts and fetched them the way most AI crawlers do, over plain HTTP without running JavaScript.

Table of 15 K-beauty US product pages showing Product schema present on all 15, median 1,904 words of body text, and 421 of 1,264 images with empty or missing alt text

COSRX and TIRTIR leave well over half their images without alt text. Beauty of Joseon leaves 3% without it.

Every page had structured product data and plenty of text. What was missing was the selling copy: benefit claims and how-to-use steps that existed only inside images. Here is what that looks like on pages we work on.

Side by side comparison on the Nature Republic USA aloe vera soothing gel page: a product detail section a shopper scrolls through, 8,517 pixels tall, versus the single empty-alt image tag an AI crawler receives for the same section

Nature Republic USA, Aloe Vera 92% Soothing Gel. The entire detail section is a single JPEG, 8,517 pixels tall, with no alt text. We read the text inside the image, then searched the HTML the crawler received for each line. The usage instructions and the headline concentration claim were not there.

On the Axis-Y Dark Spot Correcting Glow Serum page, the three panels that make the case for the product are three separate images, each with an empty alt attribute. The phrase "Niacinamide 5%" appears in the artwork a shopper sees and nowhere in the 1,477 words the crawler receives. The same goes for the clinical results panel and the how-to-use routine, and how-to-use is exactly the kind of question people ask an AI assistant.

Three Axis-Y product detail cards labelled Benefits, Clinical results and How to use, each tagged with an empty alt attribute, above a chart of empty-alt share for Axis-Y, Nature Republic USA and SKIN1004

Axis-Y, Nature Republic USA and SKIN1004 are all brands we work with, and we name them because the pattern is the category norm rather than one brand's mistake. All nine pages carry valid Product structured data and return 200 to every AI crawler we tested.

The reason is mechanical. Vercel and MERJ measured their own network traffic and found that no major AI crawler executes JavaScript. GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and CCBot fetch HTML and parse it. Only Gemini and AppleBot render, because both ride on existing search infrastructure. Anything commercially important that only appears after a script runs is invisible, and any claim that lives only inside a JPEG is invisible too.

At least one Korean company has published numbers from fixing this. Pulmuone said in September 2026 that it restructured its official mall for generative engines, including a separate AI-only product catalog, and that comparing the four months before and after April 1, site visitors rose 2.3 times and purchases 7.4 times. Those are the company's own figures, reported in the trade press, not an independent audit.

What share of AI citations comes from brand-owned websites?

2.4%. In beauty, brand-owned websites are a small slice of what AI engines cite.

Strip chart showing brand-owned websites at 2.4 percent of AI citations in beauty, with 97.6 percent going to third-party media, retail, social, and creator content

Aivo sampled 750 answers across five engines, 50 category prompts run three times each, on 18 public beauty brands.

Across 3,814 citations from 610 domains, brand-owned sites were 2.4%. The rest came from Reddit, YouTube, Ulta, Allure, Sephora, TikTok and a long list of editorial sites. That number changed our own plan.

The same study found the per-engine spread is not noise. La Roche-Posay appears in 9.3% of Claude answers and 22.0% of ChatGPT answers, with confidence intervals that do not overlap. Revlon pools to around 4% across engines while sitting at 0.7% on Google AI Overviews. It also caught an engine confidently naming Dr. Bronner's as B Corp certified in all three runs, more than a year after the brand gave that certification up.

This has limits. Nobody has published a controlled experiment showing that creator seeding causes AI citations. What the study measures is where the engines get their sources, and they overwhelmingly use third-party sites. If your entire AI search budget goes into your own domain, you are working on 2.4% of what gets cited.

Can AI engines cite product pages, or only editorial content?

They can cite both. Being cited means an AI answer names or links your page as a source, and product pages qualify. Retailer sites like Ulta and Sephora show up in the citation list above. But an engine can only quote what is in the page's text. On the K-beauty pages we tested, the strongest benefit claims sat inside images. An engine could cite those pages for their text, but not for the claims in the images.

Does traditional SEO still matter for AI search?

Yes. Traditional search position still matters, and the research says so directly. In C-SEO Bench, being in the first two positions remained significant across domains. Google's own guidance for AI experiences is mostly the old guidance: make sure the page returns a 200, is crawlable, and has indexable content.

Do not rebuild your business around AI referral traffic yet. SparkToro and Similarweb put US zero-click Google searches at 68.01% in the first four months of 2026, up from 60.45% in 2024, so clicks are disappearing. But the same analysis puts AI tools at under 1% of all referral traffic. People are getting answers without clicking, but AI tools still send very little traffic.

And do not trust a single measurement. One arXiv paper from April 2026 argues visibility has to be treated as a distribution rather than a single-point outcome, because answers vary across runs, prompts, and time. Another from May 2026 audited 2,000 runs and found that just adding a description of the asker to the prompt cut the similarity of the recommendation lists by 0.12 to 0.20. Category leaders held steady at around 80% consistency. Mid-market brands saw up to 75% of the recommendation set swap out depending on who the model thought was asking. Most K-beauty brands entering the US are mid-market.

How do you measure AI citations for blog posts versus product pages?

Use the free reports from the search engines themselves. Bing Webmaster Tools opened AI Performance in February 2026. It shows citation counts and the queries that grounded an AI answer in your page, so you can see whether your blog posts or your product pages are the ones being cited. Google rolled its generative AI performance reports out to all sites by August 31, 2026. Both are first-party and free, so there is no need to buy a tracker yet.

Measure each engine separately. As the overlap data above shows, being cited by one engine says little about the others.

How should a beauty brand optimize for AI search?

Make your product claims readable as text, measure citations engine by engine, and put most of the budget into creator, retailer, review and editorial content.

Check the switch before optimizing anything. As of August 31, 2026, every Search Console property has a Search generative AI control under Settings. It defaults to include, but if it is set to exclude, your AI Overviews and AI Mode impressions are zero regardless of what else you do.

Put commercially critical content in the initial HTML response. Price, ingredients, claims, availability. If it only exists after JavaScript runs, assume no AI crawler outside Gemini and AppleBot will ever see it.

Write the alt text, and put the claim in text as well as in the artwork. For K-beauty this is the highest-yield fix, because the benefit story sits inside image files with empty descriptions.

Measure per engine with the free reports above. Bing's AI Performance report and Google's generative AI reports cost nothing, so skip the paid tracker for now.

Spend the rest on sites you do not own. Creator videos, review threads, retailer pages and editorial coverage are 97.6% of what the engines cite in this category. It is the same earned-media work brands already do, and now an AI engine reads it too.

Skip the llms.txt, and don't spend time expanding FAQ schema.

Which agency can help a K-beauty brand show up in US AI answers?

The agencies that can help are the ones that build what AI engines cite: US creator content, reviews on retailer pages and product pages with their claims in text. Be wary of any that guarantees a spot in AI answers. In Aivo's beauty sample, 97.6% of citations went to sites brands don't own: creator videos, review threads, retailer pages and editorial coverage. A useful agency gets real US creators using and talking about your product and gets reviews onto the retailer pages where you sell. It also makes sure your own product pages state their claims in text.

Your own site still matters for one kind of question. In a small test on September 30, we asked ChatGPT with web search eight questions about marketing K-beauty in the US, four in English and four in Korean. bazzaal.com was cited in three of the answers, all to questions whose answer was an agency name, and the cited pages were our homepage and case studies. For general how-to questions, the sources were third-party sites.

Before you sign, ask three things. Which engines does it measure, and can it show citation data from Bing's or Google's own reports? What does it do beyond llms.txt and schema? And what evidence does it have? A few tactics showed effects in limited tests, but none can guarantee AI placement for a particular brand, and that includes creator seeding.

BAZZAAL works on the creator side of that layer. From Los Angeles, we seed K-beauty products with US creators so real reviews and videos exist before shoppers start asking. That is top-of-funnel work: it puts your product in front of US shoppers early and leaves the engines something to cite. We do not sell guaranteed AI placement.

Talk to us about US creator seeding →

Related: why category beats origin · creator seeding at scale · selling K-beauty on TikTok Shop in the US

Sources

  1. Pew Research Center, "Americans and AI 2026," June 17, 2026.

  2. Mistral, Meta, Alibaba, Anthropic and OpenAI crawler documentation, retrieved September 23, 2026.

  3. Brave Search API documentation.

  4. Writesonic citation overlap study, July 22, 2026.

  5. Aggarwal et al., "GEO: Generative Engine Optimization," KDD 2024.

  6. "C-SEO Bench," NeurIPS 2025 Datasets and Benchmarks.

  7. SAGEO Arena, KDD 2026.

  8. Google Search Central guidance on AI features and crawler documentation updated July 14, 2026.

  9. Ahrefs llms.txt study, June 15, 2026.

  10. Openads report, August 2026.

  11. Vercel and MERJ, "The rise of the AI crawler."

  12. The PR, report on Pulmuone, September 22, 2026.

  13. Aivo, "Beauty Representation Report," July 17, 2026.

  14. SparkToro and Similarweb zero-click study, June 2026.

  15. arXiv 2604.07585 and arXiv 2605.30207.

  16. Product page measurements, crawler fetch tests, and the detail-section audits are our own, run September 2026.

Product imagery is from the brands' own storefronts.

Yong Suk Choi, Chief Business Officer, BAZZAAL

Written by

Yong Suk Choi

Chief Business Officer

Chief Business Officer at BAZZAAL. 15+ years of zero-to-one go-to-market execution across Korean and US markets, now leading growth for K-beauty brands entering the US from Los Angeles and Seoul.

Connect on LinkedIn

Planning your US launch?

BAZZAAL runs creator seeding, TikTok Shop, and paid campaigns for K-beauty brands entering the US — from Los Angeles, in Korean-company workflows.

Subscribe to STATESIDE

Weekly US K-beauty intelligence, from our team on the ground in LA.

Ready to be the next big thing in beauty?

It's time to take your brand somewhere new!

Beauty creators posing together for a group photo

Ready to be the next big thing in beauty?

It's time to take your brand somewhere new!

Beauty creators posing together for a group photo

Ready to be the next big thing in beauty?

It's time to take your brand somewhere new!

Beauty creators posing together for a group photo
>